Are you going to do something in particular with the data where you need those extra score dimensions? If not, you might consider just tracking in Goodreads instead: http://www.goodreads.com/ – you’ll get a lot of metadata and aggregate review data about the books for free.
I too have been tracking books read in Libreoffice Calc (Excel alternative) since 4 years (and movies seen since 9 years).
4-6: Great idea of you to separate value, readibility and entertainment, that is an excellent scoring system. I actually stopped grading my books because I only gave 1 score per book but found that too difficult because some books are extremely high value, but low on readability and entertainment, or otherwise around.
Regarding ‘scoring’ your books, I also noticed this: manytimes if I would look at the score a few months or more after reading, I would be surprised how high I scored the book right after reading it, because a few months later I would not remember the book as that good. It was like right after reading a book, because I was still ‘into it’ or something, I would feel much more enjoyment from the book, than I later would remember having felt. If that makes sense.
7: I also note
where I purchased, or whom I borrowed the book from
date of purchase (this is often waaaaaaaay before date of start reading, my yet-to-read pile is always high )
wheter it’s a paperback, hardcover or e-book
also interesting to note: how you got the idea to read this book, i.e.: recommended by friend, or because I want to read more of this author I already know&like, or because of an article on internet/paper/magazine, or because I saw the movie…
how much I paid for the book, if applicable
8: Don’t really understand what you mean by ‘weights’ ??
I’ve used LibraryThing.com since 2005 or so. Free for under 200 books. Quite extensive, but can’t add custom fields like readability, for example, if I remember correctly. I’ve also found the process for adding a book somewhat cumbersome.
Firstly, thanks for all the comments to my thread. This is a great community.
Secondly, I finally managed to eke out some time and finished making my tracker. I’m attaching it here. Feel welcome to use and share and come back with your review comments (if any).
I really like the simplicity of this excel tracker! I uploaded it to a public Google spreadsheet in case anyone wants to use it. You can access that file here.